Charming Historical Retreats in Cape May

Spacious villa and cottage near beaches and Victorian wonders

5BR/5.5BA • Ensuites • Dog Friendly • Pool

Cape May, NJ, United States
14
5
5.5

About

Spread out across 1.3 acres. 5 bedrooms, each with its own ensuite bath, no sharing. Private pool (opening June 2026), a detached cottage with foosball, and two full kitchens (one per building). Smart lock check-in. Pickleball, cornhole, patio with string lights & fire pit. 10 minutes to Cape May beaches; chairs, towels, umbrellas, beach toys & tags included. Cape May Reserve is where historic charm meets modern luxury. Perfect for families, celebrations, and groups ready to reconnect.

Good to know

THE ESTATE Imagine your family or friends spreading out across a 200-year-old private estate—five bedrooms, each with its own ensuite bathroom, two full kitchens, and 1.3 lush acres all to yourselves. Cape May Reserve is where historic charm meets modern luxury, designed for groups who want to be together without being on top of each other. Self check-in via smart lock — arrive on your own schedule with no coordination needed. Parking for up to 6 cars in the main driveway. THE MAIN HOUSE (4 BEDROOMS) The Main House spans two distinct wings, each with its own character. The historic wing (the original ~1825 structure) holds two King bedrooms, the living room, and dining room, all graced with original heart pine hardwood floors. One King bedroom features original exposed wooden beams and an enclosed spiral staircase; the other has a romantic clawfoot tub. The newer wing houses the expansive 500 sq ft master suite with its own private balcony, a Queen bedroom on the 1st floor, and a full modern kitchen. All four bedrooms have private ensuite bathrooms, something you rarely find in vacation rentals. Gather in the living room around the 85” TV or cook together in the fully equipped kitchen. THE COTTAGE (1 BEDROOM) Steps away from the main house is an ADU with its own entrance, king bedroom, ensuite bath, full kitchen, foosball table, and 65" Smart TV. Ideal for grandparents who want their own space, teens or kids who love their independence, a couple seeking privacy, or simply additional space for your party to enjoy. THE POOL Your private 700 sq ft heated pool is fully fenced, with an integrated sun deck, pergola for shade, and lounge furniture included. Open seasonally June through September, 8am–9pm. Whether it’s a lazy afternoon float or a sunset swim after a beach day, this is where summer memories are made. Pool access is exclusively for your group. OUTDOOR LIVING Step outside to a full outdoor living space with heated pool, asphalt pickleball court, a string-lit patio plus a wood-burning fire pit and cornhole set in the backyard, all on 1.3 private acres. The yard is naturally private, partially fenced on the street side with mature treelines providing over 100 feet of buffer on neighboring sides. Plenty of space for well-trained dogs to roam and kids to run free. (Firewood available at Acme or Wawa nearby.) THE BEACH Multiple Cape May beaches are just 5–10 minutes by car. We’ve got you covered: beach chairs, towels, 2 umbrellas, a pull cart, beach toys (boogie boards, sand castle sets, frisbee), and 10 Cape May beach tags. Just show up, everything is ready. (Beach tags must be returned at the time of checkout.) RAINY DAY? NO PROBLEM Two full kitchens invite everyone to cook together. The 85” and 65” TVs make movie marathons easy, the foosball table keeps things competitive, and the pickleball court is always there if the sun comes back out. Downtown Cape May’s shops, restaurants, and Victorian architecture are 5–10 minutes away by car. Cape May is one of the most charming small towns on the East Coast, rain or shine. UNIQUE FEATURES • Self check-in via smart lock — arrive any time • Private heated pool — 700 sq ft, fully fenced (June–Sept, 8am–10pm) • Every bedroom has its own private ensuite bath • 200-year-old original heart pine hardwood floors (historic wing only) • Preserved servant staircase, a fascinating piece of living history • Clawfoot tub in one of the historic King bedrooms • Pickleball court on asphalt with equipment and net provided • Foosball table in the cottage • Cornhole set — stored outdoors, played in the backyard • Walking distance to Cape May Winery & Vineyard • Parking for up to 6 cars • 1.3 private acres with natural treeline privacy PERFECT FOR Family reunions, milestone birthdays, wedding party accommodations, bachelorette weekends, holiday gatherings, multi-generational vacations, and summer beach weeks. If your group values space, privacy, and character—this is your place. WHAT WE PROVIDE • Eco-friendly shampoo, conditioner, body wash, hand soap, lotion (refillable dispensers) • Complimentary medium roast coffee, creamer, sugar (Main House); Nespresso machine in the Cottage • Fresh linens and towels (plus dark washcloths for makeup removal) • Hair dryer in every bathroom • WiFi, central heat & AC throughout • 2 sets of Washer & dryer • Beach chairs, towels, 2 umbrellas, pull cart & beach toys • 10 Cape May beach passes (must be returned at checkout)

Availability

What this place offers

Amenities

Common

  • Air conditioning
  • Cleaning products
  • Cooking basics Pots and pans, oil, salt and pepper
  • Dishes and silverware
  • Dryer In the building, free or for a fee
  • Essentials Towels, bed sheets, soap, toilet paper, and pillows
  • Hair dryer
  • Heating Central heating or a heater in the listing
  • Kitchen Space where guests can cook their own meals
  • Dedicated workspace
  • Pool
  • TV
  • Washing Machine
  • Wifi

Bathroom

  • Outdoor shower
  • Body soap
  • Conditioner
  • Hot Water
  • Shampoo

Kitchen and dining

  • Baking sheet
  • Blender
  • Coffee
  • Coffee maker
  • Dining table
  • Dishwasher
  • Freezer
  • Hot water kettle
  • Microwave
  • Oven
  • Refrigerator
  • Rice maker
  • Stove
  • Toaster
  • Wine glasses

Common

  • Air conditioning
  • Cleaning products
  • Cooking basics Pots and pans, oil, salt and pepper
  • Dishes and silverware
  • Dryer In the building, free or for a fee
  • Essentials Towels, bed sheets, soap, toilet paper, and pillows
  • Hair dryer
  • Heating Central heating or a heater in the listing
  • Kitchen Space where guests can cook their own meals
  • Dedicated workspace
  • Pool
  • TV
  • Washing Machine
  • Wifi

Bathroom

  • Outdoor shower
  • Body soap
  • Conditioner
  • Hot Water
  • Shampoo

Kitchen and dining

  • Baking sheet
  • Blender
  • Coffee
  • Coffee maker
  • Dining table
  • Dishwasher
  • Freezer
  • Hot water kettle
  • Microwave
  • Oven
  • Refrigerator
  • Rice maker
  • Stove
  • Toaster
  • Wine glasses

Location features

  • Beach access
  • Private entrance Separate street or building entrance

Outdoors

  • Beach essentials Beach towels, umbrella, beach blanket, snorkeling gear
  • Fire pit
  • Outdoor seating
  • Patio

Bedroom and laundry

  • Bed linens
  • Extra pillows and blankets
  • Hangers
  • Room-darkening shades
  • Clothing storage

Family

  • Board games

Home safety

  • Carbon monoxide detector
  • Fire extinguisher
  • First aid kit
  • Smoke detector

Parking and facilities

  • Free parking on premises

House Rules

HOUSE RULES No Early-checkin or late checkout available in peak season due to tight turnover window. Age Requirement - All guests must be 25 years or older unless accompanied by a parent or guardian Occupancy - No additional guests or visitors without prior approval No Smoking Policy - Absolutely no smoking inside the house or on balconies/decks - Violation will result in a minimum $300 additional cleaning fee Quiet Hours & Neighbor Courtesy - Quiet hours: 10:00 PM - 8:00 AM - Outdoor music ends at 9:00 PM - Though this is a very large property, please be mindful and respectful of neighbors at all times - Please keep noise levels reasonable 🐾 PET POLICY Dogs only, under 30 lbs (strictly enforced). Must be house-trained, well-behaved, and up to date on vaccinations. - Maximum 2 dogs - Vaccination records required (rabies, distemper, bordetella) - Undeclared pets: May result in immediate cancellation without refund - Dogs must not be left unsupervised - Not permitted in pool area - Please clean up after your dog and wipe paws before entering - No dogs on furniture unless covered with guest's blanket - Any pet damage charged to guest 🏊 POOL RULES (Seasonal: June - September) - Pool hours: 8:00 AM – 9:00 PM - No diving — shallow end only - Children must be supervised at all times by an adult - No glass, breakables, or sharp objects in pool area - Pool furniture and loungers included with your stay - Swim at your own risk - no lifeguard on duty; owners are not liable for injuries. - Unsafe pool use may result in eviction without refund and suspension of future bookings 🔥 FIRE PIT RULES - Fires must be attended at all times , never leave unattended - Only use seasoned firewood, no trash or accelerants - Keep fires away from structures and vegetation - Fully extinguish all fires before bed or leaving the property - Violation of fire safety rules may result in eviction without refund 🎉 EVENTS & CELEBRATIONS Small celebrations welcome with prior approval. Please reach out to host to discuss further. 📋 GUEST DECLARATIONS & COMPLIANCE What must be declared at booking: - All pets (dogs) - Total guest count (max occupancy strictly enforced) - Intended use and any special requests - Any accessibility needs Consequences of Non-Compliance: - Undeclared pets: May result in immediate cancellation without refund - Occupancy violations (extra guests): Eviction without refund + potential additional fees - Unregistered overnight guests: May result in booking cancellation 🚗 PARKING - 6 vehicles maximum - Park only on the driveway and parking lot of the property 🏖️ BEACH & OUTDOOR AREAS - Please rinse sand off before entering the house - Return all beach equipment to its designated place and do not bring it inside the house 🎮 OUTDOOR GAMES & ACTIVITIES - Feel free to enjoy outdoor games and activities available on the property - Please return all outdoor game equipment to its proper storage location after use 🔧 PROPERTY CARE & DAMAGE - Please report any damage or issues immediately - Accidents happen — we appreciate prompt communication - Unreported damage may result in additional charges ♻️ TRASH & RECYCLING - Dispose of all trash using trash bags - Do not leave trash bags inside the house - Separate recyclable trash (#1-7 plastics, cardboard, metal cans, glass) from non-recyclable waste using the provided recycling bins Historic Property Care - Mind your step on 200-year-old heart pine floors, especially in doorways - Watch your head at the historic low beam entrance (one bedroom) - Do not tamper with plexiglass enclosures on preserved servant staircase - Do not hang items from or lean on historic beams - No nails, tape, or adhesive on walls or historic woodwork Toiletries & Linens - Eco-friendly refillable dispensers provided: shampoo, conditioner, body wash, hand soap, lotion - Complimentary coffee (medium), creamer, sugar - Please bring: toothbrush, toothpaste, razors, deodorant, skincare, medications - Use dark washcloths for makeup removal — do not use white towels - No hair coloring or dyeing allowed anywhere on property 👋 DEPARTURE - COMMON COURTESY - Please leave the property as you found it - Tidy up before checkout - Remove all personal belongings - Remove all food from the refrigerator and freezer - Dispose of all trash in outside bins (during extreme winter, trash can is on the porch itself) - Start dishwasher before leaving - Set the thermostat on cooling at 72°F (summer) or on heating at 68°F (winter) - Turn off lights, return beach tags to hook at the hallway - Lock all doors and windows; - Make sure no gas burners, faucets, or showers are left running

Accessibility

Neighborhood

Guest Access

Find us

Sorry we're unable to show you the location for this property

Approximate location. Full address will be provided on booking.